Modern movement shuns ‘bigger is better,’ embraces ‘less is more’
The “tiny house movement” has gained attention nationally as a reaction to the increased construction of larger homes. Popularized by the documentary “Tiny,” a television show and other media coverage, these homes are typically smaller than 1,000 square feet — a far cry from the typical American home. In 1973, the average U.S. home measured 1,660 square feet. Since then, homes in this country have grown by more than 60 percent to reach an average size of 2,598 square feet in 2013 — despite a slight dip from 2008 through 2010. The trend forces several questions. Do bigger homes with bigger payments equal more happiness? Is the lure to simplify and declutter your life worth sacrificing the square footage? Do smaller homes actually use less energy, and what factors determine how much energy a house consumes?
To each his own, as the saying goes, as to how much square footage you really need to live comfortably and keep all the belongings you treasure. Your mortgage and the electric bill are two other factors.
In general, as the size of homes increases, so do the energy demands on it. There’s additional space to be heated or cooled, more lighting is required and it’s likely that the number of appliances will increase as well. Examining only a home’s size will show a strong positive correlation between the square footage of a home and its energy consumption. To look at an extreme case, homes that measure more than 6,400 square feet (the top 1 percent of homes) use two and a half times as much electricity as those sized at 1,600 square feet. But this isn’t the whole story.
Other factors such as the age of the home, climate, income and behavior influence energy consumption as well. Energy Information Administration data shows that homes built after the year 2000 use only 2 percent more energy than homes built before 2000 even though the newer homes are, on average, 30 percent larger and contain more electronic appliances.
There are several reasons for this equilibrium in energy use despite the greater building size. First, homes are becoming more energy-efficient. They are lit with compact fluorescent lamps and light-emitting diodes instead of incandescents and use more efficient appliances. For example, an older refrigerator can use about twice as much energy as a newer model of similar capacity. Second, homes are being built with more energy-efficient features. These include better building shells, modern windows and more insulation. Larger homes in particular are more likely to include these types of energy-saving features. These changes are due not just to technological advances but policy changes that tightened building codes and raised the minimum energy-efficiency standards for appliances. Programs such as EnergyStar have helped to educate consumers about the efficiency and cost-savings of their products. Lastly, more Americans are moving south to more moderate climates. This means that less energy is used on space heating, and although the southern migration has resulted in a 56-percent increase in energy used for air conditioning, it’s not enough to offset the space-heating reduction.
What this ultimately means is that the amount of energy a home uses is not predetermined by its size. While moving into a tiny home may not be practical or possible (they are often not allowed under current zoning regulations and only make up around 1 percent of homes), realize that large and small homes alike have the potential to be efficient or inefficient.
Rather than moving into a tiny home to save energy, consider looking into energy-efficient retrofits. Contact your local electric cooperative for ways to save.
Thomas Kirk is a technical research analyst specializing in energy efficiency and renewable energy for the Cooperative Research Network, a service of the Arlington, Va.-based National Rural Electric Cooperative Association.
Do you enjoy compact living?
If you’ve downsized your living quarters or already have a tiny home, let us know. We are compiling local and regional interest for further articles and features on the subject, and we’d love to talk with you.
What impact has it made in your life? Has it affected your bottom line? Has it freed you up to do things you perhaps weren’t able to do before such as travel or invest? Email us at [email protected] and include “Tiny Home Feedback” in the subject line.